Last month, I got an opportunity to have a brief session with former ambassador T. P. Sreenivasan as part of an internship programme. Before the day itself, our coordinators asked us to come up with some questions. The moment I got the information about the session and saw Sreenivasan's picture in the brochure, I was ready with my question. It was related to the hapless incident that happened when he was assuming the post of Vice-Chairman of the Kerala State Higher Education Council. In Kovalam, he was smacked down by SFI members who were protesting against the proposal of establishing private universities in Kerala. However, the SFI recriminated that the slap was a sudden reaction to Sreenivasan's verbal abuse of some student. But the greatest irony unfolded when the previous Left government itself tabled the Private Universities Bill in the Kerala Legislative Assembly. I thought it would not be wise to ask about this incident, so I planned to use this as an opener and ask how we can ensure accountability, affordability, and transparency won't get compromised with the arrival of private universities. But destiny or Sreenivasan—had other plans. While answering the first question (asked by another fellow) itself, he elaborated on all this stuffs. Now I was put on the spot to ask directly without any added flavours. Since that wouldn't satisfy me, I decided to ask something else, something from his domain itself: international relations.
My question was simple and straightforward: as someone who started his career when the world was bipolar and ended it when it was largely unipolar, in which direction do you think the world order is marching forward now? His response was verbose, which unfortunately fell short of hitting core my query. However, this in no way belittles his efforts and the genuine warmth he shared with us. But I reckon the question remains crucial in international politics, and a picture of three world leaders sitting around a massive roundtable in the city of Shenzhen was providing some hints.
The trilateral meeting on the sidelines of the APEC summit attended by Chinese President Xi Jinping, Russian President Vladimir Putin, and USA President Donald Trump has captured eyeballs for many reasons. Firstly, it was unprecedented to see the leaders of the three current global powers coming together and having discussions. Pundits across the world highlight the event as the next world order; however, the meeting itself hasn't produced any substantial material, which we will discuss later. As each nation has different imperatives, it is more sensible to discuss each separately.
China choosing Shenzhen as the summit destination itself has a subtle message. Journalists and correspondents are astonished by the grandeur and surrealism of the city. Robots serving coffee, welcoming guests, and dancing is part of the message that China is no longer an advancing middle-power nation. Xi himself receiving Donald Trump at the airport can be part of redefining power optics, along with placating relationships between countries, especially in the economic sphere. Both leaders met four times this year, which clearly shows the path forward. China, through its state-sponsored corporations, Belt and Road Initiative and financial lending, domination over supply chains, and semiconductor industry, has extended its arms across the globe. The USA, let alone any other country, has the leverage to shun China at the moment. The decision by the USA last September to extend the trade truce until 2027 is one of the latest testimonies to verify that. The exciting area would be how the USA is going to recalibrate its Indo-Pacific policy in the background of China's ongoing transgressions neglecting the rules-based order. With allies like Taiwan and Japan, and partners like Southeast Asian countries facing skirmishes with China, the USA is now in rough waters. With regard to Russia-China relations, both countries have escalated their strategic partnership in recent years, and the camaraderie both leaders share is at its epitome. China's silent support for Russia's special military operation in Ukraine and help navigating European sanctions has strengthened that relationship.
For Russia, this is a re-entry moment into power-politics posturing after a hiatus, as they have been occupied with a war at home for four years against Ukraine. Putin's statement that this meeting is a "new chapter in the history of diplomacy", and his passive acceptance in comparing it with the Yalta Conference of 1945, reflects an attempt to showcase Russian strength. However, to be honest, Russia doesn't have its old economic might, but they have transcended the limits placed by the world, especially Europe. The sanction plan of NATO aimed at curbing oil and gas trade, which would eventually hit the Russian economy, has failed miserably. The recent USA deal to buy diesel from Russia unveiled another hypocrisy of the former, as USA Trade adviser Peter Navro once made a slander that Ukraine war is "Modi's war" for India buying Russian oil at a discounted rate. Europe is now in a labyrinth as Trump's inconsistency with regard to NATO's post-World War security architecture is becoming evident. Trump's relation with Russia, and Putin particularly, is often inexplicable and is creating tension in Europe's security calculus. Considering the war too, albeit Russia is suffering losses including the recent Kerch Bridge attack, they hold the upper hand by capturing around 20% of Ukrainian territory. Thus, Russia used Shenzhen as a platform to reaffirm to the world that they are in the game.
The United States, through Trump, has broken convention and has now reached out to two adversaries on equal footing. Even though no considerable agreements were made, the summit depicts a clear picture to the world. Trump's attendance comes in the backdrop of a debacle in the midterm polls, losing the majority in both the Senate and Congress. His position has also been marred by the Iran war, to an extent that his Vice President J. D. Vance called out the war as one of the reasons for the defeat. One of the talking points of the meeting, reducing the risk of nuclear weapons makes some sense, since the final nuclear agreement, the New START (Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty) between USA and Russia, expired months back. It should be noted here that no talk hovered around in the actual reduction of nuclear weapons; however, Trump, it is said, asserted attacking Iran as a part of nuclear risk reduction. A wise calculation also suggests that the USA is trying to find a sensible formula in a changing world order rather than creating poles.
The summit was named the U.S–Russia–China Heads of State Declaration toward Peace. Yet no roadmap or concrete step for global peace was formed and whether these countries take credible steps in coming days, is a matter of another question. Besides peace and nuclear risk reduction, the meeting also discussed the ineffectiveness of international courts and the reforms needed in multilateral bodies. All three countries agreed upon the misuse of jurisdiction by the International Criminal Court. Pundits consider this approach to be rekindling the "might is right" theory by sidelining international arbitration, as all of these countries face trials in one way or another. About the reforms, especially in the United Nations, as Sreenivasan said during the discussion, no UNSC permanent member wholeheartedly supports its expansion. Thus, a deadlock remains intact in the United Nations, particularly in the UNSC, which is not going to be disturbed anytime soon.
Soon after the roundtable picture was released, Rahul Gandhi posted on X claiming that if Congress were in power, India's Prime Minister too would have been there and that PM Modi is compromised. Former diplomat Kanwal Sibal responded that Gandhi's claims are baseless as India is not a member of APEC. Though Sibal is true with the facts, it is important to understand that any new world order should have the presence of middle-power countries like India, Brazil, and South Africa. Thus, if there is any sort of contrived plan behind the curtains to create a trilateral world, none of the three has the room to do that right now.
Open for criticism
nithalrahman@gmail.com
Nithal S Rahman
Comments
Post a Comment